Pairing Picture Books and Primary Sources: Earmuffs for Everyone! by Meghan McCarthy

Earmuffs for Everyone

Earmuffs for Everyone

The blast of cold weather in St. Louis led me to find all my winter gear. That reminded me of Meghan McCarthy’s book Earmuffs for Everyone. Reading the book led me on a hunt for primary sources in the form of patents, something new for me and my students.

Earmuffs for Everyone gives an account of Chester Greenwood who is attributed with inventing earmuffs or at least the steel band that kept them fitted on the head. It also, with patents as a backdrop, looks at solutions others came up with to keep ears warm. The book also explores other inventions patented by Chester Greenwood and explains what a patent is.

Searching for Patents as Primary Sources

Ear and Neck Protector

Ear and Neck Protector

With patents being such a strong underpinning for this book, it seemed like a natural fit to use the actual patents as primary sources. This was a format of primary source that I had not used before. Starting at the US Patent and Trademark Office, I realized that to search for patents prior to 1976 I needed the actual patent number. Not having that, I turned to Google Patents for my initial search. Searches for “ear protection,” “ear muffs,” and “Chester Greenwood” led me to original images of patent designs. Listed on those original images was the patent number. That allowed me to return to my original search where I could also find the full patent including the original description of the patented item.

Finding patents that matched images in the book as well as other patents for ear protection from the same time period, I was able to curate a set of primary sources that could be used to extend the learning from the book.

Pairing the Picture Book and Patents

Ear mufflers

Ear mufflers

There are many ways these patents could be used with Earmuffs for Everyone focusing on primary sources, literacy, and STEM activities. Students can begin by reading the book or having the book read to them. This gives them valuable background about patents and makes viewing the primary sources much easier. Students will likely also enjoy making connections between the illustrations in McCarthy’s book and the patent drawings.

After reading the book, students activities could vary depending on age, learning focus, reading ability, time, or additional available resources. They could include:

  • Students describe or write how they think the invention works or, in this case, should be worn or put on by viewing the patent drawing.
  • Viewing only the written specifications for the patent (clicking on the link to drawing and then looking at the navigation bar on the left of the web page), creating a drawing of the earmuffs or ear protection based on the written description.
  • Chester Greenwood’s patent was actually an improvement on existing earmuffs. Students can brainstorm how a invention shown in a patent could be improved upon, especially based on new technology. For example, instead of clasps and buckles, velcro may make some devices more comfortable and easier to wear.
  • Several patents in the curated set are actually part of a hat. Redesign the invention based on hats typically worn today.
  • Create a prototype of the invention based on the visual and written description. Depending on what materials and tools you have, this could be part of a makerspace activity or collaboration with an art teacher. If creating a prototype, try wearing it outside. How does that impact your feeling about the device?

However students learn with the patents as inspiration and the picture book providing entertaining background context, they can be creative and challenged in their thinking.


Author: Tom Bober

Tom Bober is a school librarian at RM Captain Elementary, 2018 Library Journal Mover and Shaker, former Teacher in Residence at the Library of Congress, and author of the upcoming book Elementary Educator’s Guide to Primary Sources: Strategies for Teaching. He writes the Picture Books and Primary Sources posts for AASL’s KQ blog and has written articles for several publications. Tom also presents at conferences, runs workshops, and gives webinars to promote the use primary sources in student learning. He began his career as an elementary classroom teacher, was also an educational technologist, and has spent the last nine years as a school librarian.

Categories: Blog Topics, STEM/STEAM, Student Engagement/ Teaching Models

3 replies

  1. One of my favorite books is Susan Hall’s Using Picture Story Books to Teach Literary Devices (Vol 4)… and i have used it often.

    This Christmas I paired stuffed animals with picture books for my younger grandchildren.. it’s nice to cuddle with a stuffed animal while listening to the story.

    However, Tom, you take this to a new level. I never thought about searching Google Patents to go with a picture book about earmuffs!

    Loved this post…. Good job!

  2. Excellent article! I was a school librarian for 29 years, and I always loved pairing picture books with nonfiction. If I hadn’t retired last year, I would be busily searching Google Patents for ideas for pairings that worked with our curriculum!

  3. It was crazy that I ran across this article today. I was actually planning on using this book to work on nonfiction texts and summarizing using Main Idea and Key Details. Now I have a new angle to take. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.